Brain-death Draft Law Stirs up Controversy in China

Home>>China

Last updated at: (Beijing Time) Tuesday, September 03, 2002

Brain-death Draft Law Stirs up Controversy in China

Chinese legislators and medical workers have held heated discussions in the past few days on whether or not it is correct to have a law defining brain death.

DISCUSSION

CHINESE

SEND TO FRIEND

Chinese legislators and medical workers have held heated discussions in the past few days on whether or not it is correct to have a law defining brain death.

The debate was inspired by remarks by Vice-Minister of Health Huang Jiefu. Last Wednesday, he said that his ministry had completed draft criteria for determining brain death.

Arguments for and against brain-death legislation have raged for more than two decades in China, where death is traditionally and legally defined as "the cessation of respiration and blood circulation."

The moment of most deaths is regarded as the time when breathing stops and the heart stops beating.

According to traditional idea, organ transplants should be performed only after the organ donor has stopped breathing and when the heart has stopped beating. But the other organs have usually become useless by then.

Chen Zhonghua, a professor from Tongji Hospital in Wuhan in central China's Hubei Province, said that the law on brain death must be strictly based on medical science, widespread public acceptance and a sound legal environment.

Some experts said China does not yet have the conditions needed to implement a law on brain death.

Many doctors in China still lack the necessary skill, knowledgeor equipment to correctly determine brain death, and so the improvement of medical training and hospital conditions is urgent.

Liu Gexin, a professor from the Beijing-based China University of Politics and Law, said China need establish legally-recognized medical criteria on brain death, rather than a law as such.

Questions?Comments? Click here

China Draws up Law on Brain Death

Highly Concerning China, US Plans to Deploy New Fighters in Guam ( 5 Messages)

Japanese Court Dismisses Germ Warfare Victims' Damages Claim ( 3 Messages)

China Plans to Stop the Overeas Flight of Corrupt Officials ( 14 Messages)

China's Exports Hit Record of US$56.2 Billion in July ( 96 Messages)

Old Chinese Beaten by NY Police, Triggers off Big Clash ( 47 Messages)