Latest News:  

English>>World

Comment: Lessons from Egyptian irony

(China Daily)

08:56, July 08, 2013

The difficulty in judging Egypt's latest political development stems from confusion over what kind of democracy to embrace

The Egyptian military's decision to remove President Mohamed Morsi from power and suspend the constitution was said to be a response to days of mass street protests demanding the president step down. That huge crowds celebrated in Cairo's Tahrir Square amid clashes between opponents and supporters of Morsi in 12 governorates across the country, which left at least 30 people dead and more than 1,000 injured by Sunday, is clear testimony of how serious the divides are in Egyptian society.

Confrontation between secular and religious forces and the showdown between an elected president and the military have pushed Egypt's democratization process to a new turning point.

Morsi was the country's first president elected through a national poll after the Egyptian people put an end to the Hosni Mubarak administration in 2011. So the government of Morsi and his party was endowed with legitimacy. Judging from the means and effect of Morsi's ousting, the military's move is no different from any other military coup.

However, over the past year, Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood displayed a strong desire to establish a monopoly on power, not only repeatedly going back on previous promises to limit their power, but also failing to meet the demands of the people in terms of economic growth and social management.

Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood's strong desire for power, incompetence in managing state affairs, coupled with their increasing favor for a constitution inspired by Sharia law, made a number of intellectuals and secular liberals that once supported Morsi and some liberal-leaning Muslim forces stand against him. They thought that although Morsi came to power through democratic means he was proving to be a new "pharaoh" and the policies his government was pursuing ran counter to the democracy they believe in.

Yet it is ironic that when the opposition's call for presidential elections ahead of time in a bid to end the one-year rule of Morsi in a democratic way proved futile, the angry opposition forces chose to provoke a non-democratic military operation to oust the elected president.

Supporters of the coup say that the army's move pulled Egypt's derailed democratization process back on track, while critics argue it was a sign of the country's backwardness and was non-democratic.

The army's move also left the United States, which likes to hold high the banner of freedom and democracy, in confusion. The White House has so far made only vague statements calling on the army to move "quickly and responsibly" to return "full authority" to an elected civilian government.

In fact, the difficulty in judging Egypt's latest political development stems from observers' different views about the result, means and motivation. In the final analysis, this is the reality of a worldwide confusion over what kind of democracy developing countries in transition should embrace, and how to find a suitable way to realize that democracy.

With struggling economies, immature democratic cultures and the lack of any social consensus, the "Arab Spring" that led to the fall of strongman regimes resulted in power and even belief vacuums in some North African countries. While protesters succeeded in overthrowing the old regimes, they failed to unite and rally the strength to find a new path.

If the political change in Egypt brings democracy back on track, it will be a blessing for the Egyptian people. Adli Mansour, head of the Supreme Constitutional Court, who was sworn in as interim leader on Thursday, has offered an olive branch to the Muslim Brotherhood by saying that there will be "no exclusion of anyone" under his rule, and he wants them integrated into the nation. But supporters of the ousted ruling party are calling for new protests amid news of an anti-Islamist crackdown.

An election has been promised, although no date has yet been set, but who can guarantee the country will again embark on the democratic road?

The author is a senior fellow with the Chahar Institute and a researcher with the Institute of West Asian and African Studies at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.

We Recommend:

U.S. presidents and their pets

Highlights of 50th Int'l Paris Air Show

Best photos of week (June 17 - June 23)

Venezuelan Army School boat visits Cuba

Afghan refugees at UNHCR registration center

Beauty contest held in Budapest, Hungary

Angelina Jolie visits refugee camp

'Super moon' hangs in the sky over Rotterdam

LA' Chinatown sets up statue of Bruce Lee

Email|Print|Comments(Editor:LiangJun、Yao Chun)

Leave your comment0 comments

  1. Name

  

Selections for you


  1. Chinese Navy opens to the public in Vladivostok

  2. Sino-Swiss free trade pact signed in Beijing

  3. Wheel of death" performed in Indonesia

  4. Photo story: Finding everlasting love

  5. Hot yoga practiced in Nanchang

  6. Sand-washing operation at Xiaolangdi

  7. Shaolin martial arts performed in Taiyuan

  8. Lotus flowers bloom in Yinchuan

  9. Jiaxing-Shaoxing Sea Bridge in E China

  10. Sales of ice cubes up in Beijing

Most Popular

Opinions

  1. Chinese-Swiss FTA, a model for cooperation with EU
  2. Witnesses' account of Xinjiang terror attacks
  3. Culture facilities should be better managed: minister
  4. Alipay, should banks worry?
  5. Chinese visitor spending brings changes to NZ
  6. Transparency urged in China's college enrollment
  7. Nokia deal will not affect business in China
  8. Obama trying to get foothold in Africa
  9. CIC needs to recruit global talent: analysts
  10. China to strengthen ties with Uganda

What’s happening in China

First panda born in Taiwan is female | Photos

  1. Taobao service: to hire someone to visit parents
  2. Memorial tablet brings soldiers' souls home
  3. Police uncover packs of chicken feet from 1967
  4. Half Year Festival celebrates family reunion
  5. Lovebirds separate when the going gets rough