Latest News:  
Beijing   Sunny/Overcast    10 / 4   City Forecast

People's Daily Online>>China Business

Chivas Brothers loses trademark lawsuit in China

(Beijing Daily)

16:05, March 13, 2012

Edited and translated by People's Daily Online

A court in Beijing rejected a request from rejected a request from Chivas Brothers, maker of Scotch whisky, to stop a Chinese company from using a similar brand name on clothing.

On July 15, 2003, a businessman surnamed Wen based in Wenzhou, Zhejiang province applied to China Trademark Office to register “Chivas Regal 88” as a trademark for garments, shoes, and hats. Chivas Brothers filed complaints but was all rejected by the office.

On Feb. 28, 2007, it applied to the Trademark Appeal Board for a review of the legitimacy of Wen’s trademark. The board ruled that Wen did not violate Chinese trademark law because the brand is used on different kinds of products. Discontent with the ruling, Chivas Brothers brought the case to the Beijing No. 1 Intermediate People’s Court.

Chivas Brothers said that Wen infringed on the company’s copyright on the Chivas Regal trademark, including its graphic design, and that Chivas Regal 88 is a knockoff of its well-known brand Chivas Regal. Furthermore, the company argued that it has already used Chivas Regal on clothing.

The court said Chivas Brothers did not have enough evidence to prove that the whiskey brand was already “well-known” in China before the registration of Chivas Regal 88. The company also cannot prove that the design of its whiskey brand was completed and unveiled before the time Wen registered Chivas Regal 88.

In addition, Chivas Brothers has used Chivas Regal on the uniforms for its salespeople, not on clothing for commercial sale. The court ruled against Chivas Brothers because there was insufficient evidence to support the company’s claim that Wen illegally used its well-known brand.

Email|Print|Comments(Editor:马茜)

Leave your comment2 comments

  1. Name

Whyi nolong bychn at 2012-03-1576.248.170.*
This is why i no longer buy Chinese. good luck being a thief in the long run.
wende at 2012-03-1371.255.86.*
Trademark issue should only be applicable if the items sold are of the same industry. If a Chinese company sells liquor under Chivas name, then it is an encroachment of trademark. However, in this case, the Chinese company should have alter the name a little bit like "Chivas88" or "Chivas Royale"
  

Selections for you


  1. "Little Potala Palace" attracts millions of tourists

  2. Chinese version of Charles III rehearsed in Beijing

  3. Chinese medical team leaves for Liberia

  4. Animals enjoy spring sunshine

Most Popular

Opinions

  1. China's diplomacy needs courage and strategy
  2. Death penalty does not hold answer to corruption
  3. Socialist democracy to illuminate China's future
  4. Truth about Tibet is slowly coming to light
  5. Expert: Glitter of foreign diploma to fade away
  6. NPC reform reflects vote of confidence
  7. Facing problems forges confidence for development
  8. Defense budget guards peaceful intentions
  9. Will China's economy keep growing or slow down?
  10. Chinese products bring benefits to U.S. consumers

What's happening in China

Thousands of pupils get nutrition improved in Sichuan, China

  1. Collapsed cement storage tank kills 2 in E China
  2. 990 mln yuan retrieved for disgruntled consumers
  3. China's Datong to hold solar energy 'Olympics'
  4. S. China shipwreck kills at least two
  5. No more "chicken without sex life" at restaurants

PD Online Data

  1. Spring Festival
  2. Chinese ethnic odyssey
  3. Yangge in Shaanxi
  4. Gaoqiao in Northern China
  5. The drum dance in Ansai